Again, it sounds like you are doing the right things.
I was glad to see you write this:
I've told him point blank that if he can't make the commitment to me, if he can't cut it off or chooses her in any way, I'm prepared to walk away. I know it will be really hard to do, but if I have to, I have to.
That was the right thing to say.
It’s impossible to conceive of when you’re fresh past DDay and you still love the man who hurt you so unbelievably, but recovering from infidelity is actually a paradox, perhaps a catch-22. Let me explain.
Betrayed spouses who say "I want to go all in and try and save my marriage, I want to be able to say I tried my best", actually most likely are giving themselves the WORST chance of saving their relationship.
In the end, doing those things that seem right and try to play pick me or push their partner into doing and saying the things they need and want to hear, actually will find they have reconciled not with a willing partner, but instead with themselves. Most likely the cheater just sees it as a chance to take things underground with their AP, as the betrayed wastes their time.
Actually your one month timeframe is not nearly enough as honestly he can’t do a damn thing for you while he still has her in her Heart. Anything he does will be inauthentic as he works with you while he still is pining for her. He can’t just turn it off like that. He can stop talking to her in and out of work, but he can’t just stop thinking of her.
What you need is for him to truly see her as a piece of shit who helped him emotionally wound the woman he vowed to love honor cherish and protect. Honestly that takes months if not years of analysis to achieve, especially when you know he still has those positive feelings for her.
No what actually gives the best chance at saving the marriage ironically also gives the best chance of ending it. It’s to end discussions and move toward divorce. He broke his vows. In a literal world that means the marriage actually ended when he fell in love with her and chose to cheat. So actually for you to make the move toward legally ending it, in my opinion, gives you the best chance down the line to save it.
There is a saying here "in order to save the marriage you have to be willing to lose it."
So if I can make up numbers here, if what you are doing gives you a 10% of rebuilding your relationship because he is still in love with her and only trying with you for a short period of time while he still sees her every day. Instead taking a hardline may give you a 30-40% of ending up together and happy again because you are showing him the true ramifications of the choice he is making with keeping her in his heart and not truly working on what is broken in him with an individual therapist.
In both cases you are more likely to end up divorced. But less likely if you take a hardline saying you’re not willing to work on anything until he works to fix himself, get her out of his life including no longer working with her, and seeing her for the crap person she really is.
Quite a paradox huh. At least by taking the latter approach you won’t be wasting your time trying to reconcile with someone who still loves and desires someone else. Until he sees you as his true one and only you minimize any chance you have at real reconciliation. It’s wasted work toward saving things.
Please just think about it and consider changing the path you are on. At the very least you’ll be more aware that there are alternatives that could leave you with better self respect and perhaps a real chance at a true building of a new relationship.
Or he will expose himself as the true idiot he is and you can move on knowing that he wasn’t in it to begin with and would have been faking it all thru that month and beyond.
Thanks for considering what I have written.