I will also chime in here about a few things (and yes I write novels - brevity is not my strong suit when it comes to discussing infidelity).
1. I agree with The1stWife - your Dad would likely not understand how MUCH you have done. Unless he has experienced infidelity himself it is unlikely you would get the feedback you are thinking you would get. By example, rarely on this site does someone who has been betrayed say "yeah, this whole nightmare is exactly what I expected." Most people who have not gone though this simply don't get it. One of my main goals when seeking an individual therapist was I wanted one who had been the betrayed side of a marriage/relationship, as after going through this I realized what I thought about affairs and their effect was just wrong AND I realized that without this experience it was not likely anyone would come anywhere close to understanding just how soul-crushing the experience is on so many levels.
I had NO CLUE what this experience would do to a person and admittedly was someone who in the past would have thought "Wow, it's been a year since X cheated on Y. Why can't Y just move on already???" This was not some kind of fundamental flaw of mine and my empathy chip is fully in tact - I just did not grasp, like at all, the level of strength and sheer will required to get through the misery and pain and the whiplash you suffer from riding the infidelity roller coaster and how LONG those injuries take to heal.
I say all this because I think it is extremely unlikely that had you told your Dad you would have gotten the feedback you hoped for. If that is the reason you want to tell him now, I would say not to bother as I think you may be disappointed in the reaction you receive. That being said, it is not too late. My Dad is also in his 80s and I think he is capable of dealing with a lot more than I give him credit for. As far as telling generally see point 2 below.
2. You said you hated:
[T]he limited circle of people a BH can tell.
I would say there is NO limit to the number of people you can tell. I get that determining who you should or should not tell is a process but keeping it all to yourself is simply too damaging. It was for me.
At d-day 1 - confrontation day - I told NO ONE aside from a single friend I have known since I was 14, who strangely enough had been the WS in a 1-year A about 10 years prior. My WH took the A underground and for a year I lived in False-R, being lied to daily, told that I was imagining things, being accused of not being able to get over it, and honestly vacillating tens of times a day between thinking my WH was lying and searching his stuff, to feeling happy, to feeling angry, to feeling miserable about myself for staying, to feeling like a marriage police officer, to feeling like a fool for staying...etc etc etc. So for a year I rode the infidelity rollercoaster, and I did so largely alone.
After d-day 2, when the ongoing A was discovered and my WH had been confronted I could not hold it all in any longer. I felt like an idiot for having believed my WH. I felt so totally defeated and unhinged that ultimately that feeling overrode everything and I had to ask myself why I had remained silent. To protect me? Sure. I did not want the judgment and the questions: "Why did you stay?" I did not want to hear "you are such a strong person - why are you putting up with this?" "Why can't you move on?" Basically I did not want to hear all of the questions I asked (or thought) about other people before infidelity showed me how wrong/uninformed/judgmental I had been. But I also had to face my own realities...as part of the reason I had not told anyone was because I was protecting my WH from that same judgment. Basically I had not told anyone because I was trying to control the outcome of the perception of others about me and my WH. But the toll it took on me during that year was so immense. There is a reason my name on this site is ThisIsSoLonely...because the isolation I felt was extreme. Had I not found this site and decided to post during that year of False R, I would have totally lost it I'm sure.
But, after I decided to tell people I found out a few things. There were few people who I cared about that did not provide me much needed support. And those who were judgmental faded from view quickly - those who cared - they outnumbered the others by far. And while my WH certainly suffered more harsh criticism from some, that was HIS burden to bear - the consequences of his choices, his actions, his flawed self - not mine. My decision to remain with him (in part - we divorced but now date) is a result of his actions after the fact, and honestly they did not come until other people knew. To use an NA/AA phase - his rock bottom was not the effect all of this had on me, but only came when he had to face what he had done in the eyes of others as well. In my opinion not telling sooner was one of my biggest errors as trying to heal largely alone - as it seems you are - was more than I should have had to bear.
3. On this issue of strength, I'm guessing you don't hate that you am stronger now and much wiser, you likely hate the fact that you became a stronger person because of infidelity. I do too. But, I cannot change what happened and how I have become the person I am today. Honestly, celebrating and knowing you can rely on these lessons can bring you some peace and self-confidence. I have much better boundaries than I used to. I have a much better sense of defending myself against behavior I feel is unacceptable. I have decidedly better communication abilities than before. AND I feel that when life throws me some other shitshow I will be much better able to handle it and recognize when I am pushing my boundaries instead of allowing them to be mowed down like a blade of grass in front of a lawnmower.
So on this front I would say you are allowing yourself to get to mired in what has happened to appreciate who YOU are now. Unlike my final point, on this issue you are in total control of how you decide to frame your newly minted strengths. I choose to hate the way my strengths were gained but the confidence in myself I have now - I know I will need that in the future at some point about something - and I'm glad I have it.
4. The aftermath and the fairness game. You said:
I hate fWW gets to rarely think about this, and I get to think about it a lot. I hate that the pain never fully goes away. I hate I cannot have real intimacy with my wife (she is in shame and won’t talk about the A anymore-1 year of counseling was enough for her). In short, I hate how unfair this is, and I have to deal with all this shit for years, and it was not my choice.
Normally when someone makes a comment like this I chime in with my own experience with the fairness game as it was eating me alive for several years - until I decided (my choice) to grasp that life is full of unfairness and embrace the lessons I have learned, not just about my WH, but more importantly about me. But in your case there is a much bigger issue bundled in your fairness comment, and I think it's the more important one one. Your WS has not helped you heal in a way that is productive to you AND (more importantly) your WS has not dealt with her part in this and come out the other side with a deeper understanding of herself flaws and all. Put another way, you are not reconciled, but instead are engaging in rugsweeping.
WH's A ended after about 2 years in a firestorm that blew up his work, the majority of his friendships, and our marriage. Only after we divorced did WS decide that he wanted to figure out why he had behaved the way he had, what allowed him to do what he did, and in his words "find out what the fuck is wrong with me." He started IC with that in mind - acceptance of the bad decisions he had made, and a total lack of understanding of how he broke not only our commitment to each other but destroyed the marriage of one of his best friends (my WH's A was with the wife of a friend and co-worker - all 3 of them worked together and he had been good friends with the OBS for years). What inside him was so needy, so lacking, that someone desiring him - finding him attractive - was worth burning all of that to the ground. Before he made that choice he was completely enveloped with shame and anger coupled with defensiveness and self-loathing - and he would talk about very little. While he would listen to me for hours, he would say little about how he felt about himself. He could apologize to me and claim he felt terrible for hurting me, but he was unable to discuss his own feelings and when he did it was in quick short sentences and usually he would turn it around to where I felt guilty because of the pain I was putting him through for asking. I also felt a loss of attraction for him and when we were intimate I completely lacked the connection to him that I formerly had - the sex was nice but it was an action - when the action was done it was done - far from what it had been before. There was no afterglow of love or connection. That was gone. At that point our relationship was a totally unsustainable shitshow. There was simply no way I could go the rest of my life with him feeling like that.
That is where I feel you may be, dear OP. And, you cannot make your WS do the work they need to do. Your words resonate with me because I felt precisely the same way - frustrated and stuck. Unsticking yourself has to happen - for you - no matter how much the initial process hurts, ripping off that bandaid is the fastest way to feel better.
I'm not telling you to divorce, but I am telling you that unless your WS makes a change - and recognizes she needs to figure her shit out AND help you get to a better place - you are better off alone. In my case we divorced but WH has been in IC for almost 4 years because he wanted to figure himself out for him - and as a result not only do I not feel the way you describe, but I am really proud of who my WH has become. He's far from perfect but he has a much better handle on his triggers, and recognizes his defensiveness and where it's coming from, is a much better participator in tough conversations - he has much more self-awareness than he had before. As it relates to me, as a result, we do still date AND I feel better about myself and about him.
So, if you have gotten this far, I would suggest you get real with your WS - and tell her exactly what you said here, and more. The burden is hers to address these issues. The burden is yours, if you choose, to stick around while she does. If you have already told her this and she is still stuck, then you have a choice: (1) accept this is as far as she is willing to go but after evaluating your reasons you would rather remain with this person then move on without her, or (2) start the process of moving on without her. As my situation suggests, you never know what will happen when you decide to move on from the relationship...but you will be able to STOP feeling like you do. And that, my friend, trust me - is worth it 1000 times over.
[This message edited by ThisIsSoLonely at 6:21 PM, Monday, September 16th]