Well brother, we won't sugarcoat the situation but hopefully we won't deliver too many 2x4's your way either.
It's a shit situation and you're in for a rough ride. I'm sorry. Start drinking lots of water, and start getting good sleep and exercise. Try to avoid alcohol.
You were doing what is called the "pick me" dance. It's very common so don't beat yourself up. But I think you realize now what happened. Consider reading "No More Mr. Nice Guy" by Glover and start a hard 180 on your wife. The 180 is described her on SI in several articles. No more pick me dance.
There are things you can do to take control now and get yourself out of this.
A couple of observations:
"It meant nothing" "That guy means nothing"
A lot of WS's (wayward spouses) say this, but it is an empty phrase, because it sure means something to you now, doesn't it? She's also saying this, apparently, in the context of you seeing texts she sent to the OM (other man) declaring her love for him.
Next time she tries this phrase, tell her to stop saying it because her stepping out on the marriage means everything.
It has devastated the marriage. It is an irrevocable act, which is one of a myriad of reasons why it is in the Ten Commandments.
Like murder, it is an act that creates a rift in time and space. Things can never be the same. There is no time machine. The old marriage is dead. I mean that literally not metaphorically.
"I was confused but now I'm not"
I think you can see what a bunch of word salad nonsense this is. Your wayward wife (WW) is very confused and a very broken person.
This is who she is, not who you thought she was. Not the woman you idealized when you married.
"Now I know I just want you"
She doesn't get to decide that now -- only you do.
"I was wondering what an open relationship would be like."
Paired with her desire to be "out in the dating world" you're seeing a peek at her internal narrative. This is deeply troubling because your WW has an engrained worldview, a life philosophy that allows her to treat sacred marital vows as conditional based on her own standards. It could take years to unravel this worldview.
You've got a lotta life to live and probably don't want to spend most of it "fixing" someone like this. Really.
I'm really struggling on if I should divorce her or not; this is not the first time I've suspected anything but it's the first time I've obtained proof.
This is troubling. Are you suggesting you believe she may have been unfaithful with other men in the past? If that's the case, then you're dealing with a serial cheater -- and it's rare that you can do anything with a serial cheater but divorce them. Quickly.
She even was saying one slip up in 14 years is not abnormal and she allows or would forgive me if I was on the other side.
I'm sure you understand already how offensive and ridiculous this is. This wasn't a slip up or a mistake. She verbalized her desire to do it, telegraphed it for you, then carried it out. This was a series of deliberate choices and actions to deceive you and then to betray you. She allowed another man to penetrate her and then came home to you. Think about that.
A mistake, as has already been pointed out, is forgetting something at the grocery store. Mistakes can even have terrible consequences, but they are still mistakes. Adultery is not a mistake. She didn't trip and accidentally stumble open-legged onto another man's genitalia.
That was planned and carried out deliberately.
"I'm going to go have my fun plowing this teenager, then when I'm done, I'll come back to my faithful comfortzone and you're gonna just to just deal with it"
Yes, this is exactly what she did. Good for you to be thinking so clearly already. This is known as plan A/plan B cake eating strategy. It looks to me like your wife is a classic "sport sex" cake eater.
An uncouth way of saying it is AFBB, but I think that is sort of overstated red pill nonsense.
The truthful part of that way of seeing it is that your WW, like every other human being, is subject to the sin of lust. She allowed herself to lust, and then carried out her lust.
So what to do?
We cannot tell you to divorce or reconcile, but we can give you some quick actions you can take now.
I will say that you are young, you haven't invested as much in this marriage as someone at midlife, and you don't have kids. In such scenarios, the usual advice here is to strongly consider divorce, rip off the band-aid quickly and move on with your life. Lots of us are trying for reconciliation for a variety of reasons. It can work, but it's a very tough slog. Most BH's who divorce quickly and move on seem to heal more rapidly.
With that in mind:
1. Ask her to write down a detailed narrative timeline of the affair. The whole truth. Everything. In detail. Many pages in length. No omissions. Part of the timeline should be disclosure on any cheating throughout your marriage. You already know a lot, but having her write the timeline accomplishes several goals:
-It forces her to confront the ugly truth in black and white
-It puts her on record so she cannot keep futzing around and fudging the facts, or tell you "I've already told you everything" in verbal convos. A written timeline puts a stop to a lot of mind games.
-It gives you information so you can make an informed decision about your future.
2. Ask her to deliver to you all texts, social media messages with the OM. Everything. No omissions. She turns over her phone to you for retrieval. She provides immediate access to all email and social media.
3. Both you and she must get tested for STD's immediately. Don't make the mistake of having what is called "hysterical bonding" sex with her. It will open up new wounds and you're already bleeding. I speak from experience. Stay celibate.
4. Tell her the timeline will be tested for truthfulness against a polygraph within the next two weeks. Make the appointment and tell her to get the timeline to you immediately, within two days. She can sit down in a chair and write it out. Part of the polygraph should ask whether she's cheated other times over the course of your 10 year marriage.
5. Make an appointment now to see an attorney so you can understand the divorce process. You may or may not decide to file, but you should at least understand your options. It's also important to see an attorney, because the 10-year mark for marriage can expose you as the betrayed husband to a greater alimony burden. I know it doesn't seem fair, but as the breadwinner you're probably going to have to pay her some form of support -- unless your state has a clause on 10 years and under.
6. Invoke a 30-90 day separation. Don't move out of your home. Ask her to move out to give you peace and the ability to heal.
7. Expose. Expose immediately to your WW's family. This isn't to exact revenge. Very important. It's to ensure your wife doesn't spin a false narrative about why you're separating. It also blows up her fantasy and makes her start dealing with reality.
I will say it's unlikely you'll ever be able to look at her the same way again.
Forgiving her would be the "easy way out" but since lies come off her tongue so effortlessly, I just have trouble even accepting her apologies and that it was a mistake, regardless of how genuine they seem.
It's very good you're seeing this. You're a lot further along than many betrayed husbands. I want to say to you that you should decouple the idea of forgiveness from whether you divorce or not. You can divorce and still forgive. Forgiveness is for you, not her.
Others will be along with more advice.
[This message edited by Thumos at 11:25 AM, June 15th (Tuesday)]